NCLT Indore Refuses To Wind Up Sai Prakash Properties, Cites Ongoing SEBI Action And Supreme Court Monitoring
The Indore Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) has refused to wind up Sai Prakash Properties Development Ltd, holding that a separate liquidation process was unnecessary when SEBI had already ordered the company to wind up its investment schemes and refund investors. A Supreme Court-appointed committee was also examining claims against the Sai Prakash group.
The Bench comprising Judicial Member Brajendra Mani Tripathi and Technical Member Man Mohan Gupta observed:
“The winding-up provisions of the Companies Act are general law. Where the special process has started and has not been shown to have failed, this Tribunal should not start a second process for the same purpose. Winding up is a last resort, not a first one. It is better considered if the regulator's process, and the process set up by the Supreme Court, are shown to be unable to give investors their money."
The SEBI process and the Special Committee aim at the same result and are better placed to reach it. The petition is maintainable, but this is not a fit case for us to use our discretion under Section 273 to wind up the Company, appoint a provisional liquidator or make any interim order.”
The petition was filed by Anil Kumar Saini, a shareholder of the company, under Sections 271 to 273 of the Companies Act, 2013, seeking its winding up.
Saini claimed that he was an original allottee of two shares and qualified as a contributory entitled to maintain the petition. He alleged that the company had collected money through land-booking offers, daily or recurring deposits, and fixed deposits. It issued certificates promising fixed amounts on maturity but failed to make the payments.
Following investor complaints, SEBI issued an interim order-cum-show-cause notice in December 2014 and a final order in July 2019. It found that the company's “Joint Venture” plans were an unregistered collective investment scheme and directed the company and its directors to wind up the schemes and refund investors with returns due. They were barred from selling or transferring assets except for making repayments.
Saini claimed that the company had enough assets to repay investors but had failed to pay amounts due on maturity. He also alleged that funds were routed through subsidiaries and related entities, many of which had not filed accounts.
The tribunal held that the petition was maintainable but declined to order winding up. It noted that SEBI's refund process and a Supreme Court-appointed committee were already addressing investor claims. A separate liquidation could disrupt these efforts, affect asset attachments and delay repayments.
The tribunal dismissed the petition, clarifying that it had not decided any investor's claim or commented on the criminal cases against the directors.
For Petitioner: Advocates Rishabh Gupta, Avani Goyal, Unnati Khajanchi