The Madras High Court has held that once parties to a settlement agreement have substantially acted upon it and received benefits under its terms, a party cannot subsequently challenge the settlement and prevent the other shareholders or directors from enjoying its benefits, including proceeding with a proposed Initial Public Offering.

A Division Bench of Justices N. Sathish Kumar and G.K. Muthukumar dismissed an appeal filed by G. Saravanan, upholding the single judge's order dated March 30, 2026 which restrained him from communicating with the BSE, Registrar of Companies, SEBI or other authorities in breach of obligations under the settlement agreement.

"Once parties to the settlement have taken advantage and acted upon substantially on the basis of the settlement, now, the appellant cannot turn around by merely filing a suit challenging the settlement and prevent the other shareholders or other Directors from enjoying the fruits of the settlement and to go for public issue also.", the Court observed. 

The dispute arose between Saravanan and other promoters and directors of NTL India Limited. Following mediation proceedings before retired Justice N. Kirubakaran, the parties executed a Memorandum of Settlement on August 13, 2024.

Saravanan received ₹13 crore as consideration including for transferring his shareholding. When the company initiated steps for an IPO on the BSE SME platform, Saravanan filed a suit alleging fraud and seeking to set aside the settlement, restore his 33.34% shareholding and recover properties and rights transferred under it. He also challenged the interim injunction granted in the suit.

The Bench observed that the settlement had been substantially acted upon and Saravanan had received consideration under it. Allegations of fraud or undue influence would require evidence and could not, by themselves, justify preventing the other parties from proceeding with the IPO.

Rejecting reliance on Section 28 of the Contract Act, the Court held that the provision was inapplicable as the settlement did not restrain anyone from pursuing legal remedies. It also noted that Saravanan had agreed not to question the settlement consideration merely because it was allegedly lower than market value.

The court held that until the alleged fraud was established in accordance with law, the settlement remained binding.

It found no infirmity in the Single Judge's order and dismissed the appeal, clarifying that the suit must be decided independently on its merits.

For the Appellant: A. Abdul Hameed, Senior Counsel, instructed by Anbarasi Rajendran.

For Respondents 1 to 3: R. Venkatavaradhan, Advocate.

Tags:    
Case Title :  G.Saravanan vs D.RameshCase Number :  OSA(CAD) No. 122 of 2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (MAD) 359