The Chennai Bench of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) on 4 November held that the absence of Input Service Distributor (ISD) registration does not, by itself, disentitle a manufacturer from claiming CENVAT credit on common input services where the services were received and the credit was supported by relevant documents.

A Bench comprising Judicial Member Ajayan T.V. and Technical Member Vasa Seshagiri Rao allowed Unique Shell Mould India Pvt. Ltd.'s appeal, setting aside the CENVAT credit demand of Rs. 2,95,206 along with interest and penalty. It said:

“..The denial of Rs.2,95,206/- is unsustainable on merits, as the absence of ISD registration, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, cannot by itself justify denial of the substantive credit, particularly when the services were received, the credit was supported by the relevant documents and no excess or double availment has been established...”

The dispute arose when the manufacturer, which produced aluminium rough castings and operated three manufacturing units, availed CENVAT credit on common input services at Unit-II, which also functioned as its registered head office, during 2010-11 to 2013-14.

The Department alleged that the credit attributable to Units-I and III should have been distributed through the ISD mechanism instead of being entirely availed at Unit-II. It issued a show cause notice proposing recovery of Rs. 2,95,206 along with interest and penalty.

The manufacturer had already reversed Rs. 1,08,729, representing the credit attributable to the other two units, along with applicable interest, and informed the Department.

However, the adjudicating authority confirmed the demand along with interest and an equivalent penalty under Rule 15(2) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, read with Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944. The Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the order.

The Tribunal noted that the Department had not disputed that the manufacturer actually received the input services, that the service providers paid the applicable service tax or that the manufacturer availed credit exceeding the tax paid. The dispute concerned only the manner in which the manufacturer accounted for and distributed the credit among its three units.

It relied on Doshion Ltd. v. CCE, Ahmedabad, Demosha Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. v. CCE & ST, Daman and the Madras High Court's decision in CCE v. Pricol Ltd., and held that non-registration as an ISD does not automatically disentitle a manufacturer from claiming CENVAT credit when the relevant records are available for verification.

Further, the Bench observed that the requirement for proportionate distribution of credit was introduced subsequently and could not be applied retrospectively to deny credit for the earlier period.

It also found that the Department had failed to establish that the manufacturer obtained any additional credit or caused any revenue loss by initially availing the credit at Unit-II.

On limitation, the Tribunal noted that the disputed credit was reflected in the manufacturer's records and that the Department had audited its accounts in 2011 and 2013.

It also took note of the manufacturer's reversal of Rs. 1,08,729 along with interest of Rs. 37,360 and its communications to the Department during 2014, before issuance of the show cause notice.

Lastly, the Bench held that mere omission or wrong availment of credit does not, by itself, amount to suppression of facts. In the absence of deliberate suppression, wilful misstatement or intent to evade payment of duty, the Department could not invoke the extended period of limitation.

Accordingly, the CESTAT set aside the demand of Rs. 2,95,206 along with interest and penalty and allowed the appeal.

For Appellant: Mr. K. Sankaranarayanan, Advocate

For Respondent: Mr. N. Satyanarayana, Authorised Representative

Tags:    
Case Title :  M/s. Unique Shell Mould India Pvt. Ltd. Plant II v. Commissioner of GST and Central ExciseCase Number :  Service Tax Appeal No. 40630 of 2017CITATION :  2026 LLBiz CESTAT(CHE) 663