On 16 November, the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Chennai, held that commitment charges collected by Punjab National Bank for keeping sanctioned loan facilities available to borrowers are liable to service tax as consideration for banking services, but the demand can be sustained only for the normal limitation period in the absence of suppression or misdeclaration.

A Bench comprising Judicial Member Ajayan T.V. and Technical Member M. Ajit Kumar differed on the taxability of commitment charges. The matter was then referred to Third Member P. Dinesha, who agreed with Kumar that the charges are liable to service tax, thereby forming the majority view. The Technical Member had observed:

“Commitment charges are charges for services rendered. It involves a clear quid pro quo, namely payment in lieu of the bank's contractual commitment to lend the sanctioned amount at a future date.”

The dispute arose after the Department found that Punjab National Bank had collected Rs. 1,14,80,950 as commitment charges from customers who did not avail of sanctioned loan facilities during 2007-08 to 2011-12.

The Department treated these charges as consideration for services under the category of “Banking and Other Financial Services” under Section 65(105)(zm) read with Section 65(12) of the Finance Act, 1994. It therefore issued a show cause notice dated 29 October 2012, demanding service tax of Rs. 12,76,769.

The adjudicating authority confirmed the demand along with interest and penalties under Sections 77 and 78 of the Finance Act. The Commissioner (Appeals) rejected the bank's appeal but set aside the penalty imposed under Section 77. Aggrieved, Punjab National Bank approached the Tribunal.

The bank contended that commitment charges were essentially interest on the undisbursed portion of sanctioned loans. It submitted that when a borrower delayed drawing down a sanctioned loan, the bank kept the funds available and charged an amount to compensate for the loss of interest.

It argued that the charges were calculated as a percentage of the undisbursed loan amount and differed from regular interest only in nomenclature. It also challenged the invocation of the extended period of limitation and imposition of penalties, contending that the issue was interpretational and that there was no suppression of facts or intent to evade tax.

The Department, on the other hand, argued that commitment charges were collected for keeping the undisbursed portion of sanctioned loan limits available to borrowers. It contended that the charges were not interest but consideration for a service rendered in relation to lending and were therefore taxable.

Technical Member's view

Member M. Ajit Kumar held that commitment charges were consideration for services rendered by the bank, involving a clear quid pro quo, namely, its contractual commitment to lend the sanctioned amount at a future date.

He observed that the payment was made for the bank's assurance that it would keep the sanctioned loan facility available to the borrower, even if the borrower chose to avail of it at a later date.

He held that such payment could not be treated as interest because it was not a charge for money lent but for the bank's commitment to make the funds available in the future. He said:

“Hence, while liability for 'interest' is based on the principle of compensation for use of the bank's money, 'commitment charge' is for the bank's contractual commitment to lend the sanctioned amount at a future date”

Further, he held that Rule 6(2)(iv) of the Service Tax (Determination of Value) Rules, 2006, excludes only interest on delayed payment of consideration for the provision of services. It does not exclude commitment charges from the taxable value.

Relying on Bank of Baroda v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Mumbai, he held that commitment charges were includible in the gross amount charged for banking services under Section 67 of the Finance Act.

Judicial Member's view

Member Ajayan T.V. disagreed with deciding the issue on merits in view of conflicting decisions of coordinate Benches of the Tribunal.

He noted that in Punjab National Bank v. CST, Raipur, the Delhi Bench had held that commitment charges were not exigible to service tax, whereas in Bank of Baroda v. CST, Mumbai, the Mumbai Bench had taken the contrary view and held such charges taxable. He stated:

“Thus, it is seen that two benches of the Tribunal have, in the case of two different Government Banks (PSU), taken diametrically opposing views on whether commitment charges are exigible to service tax in the context of a bank making available a loan to a borrower.”

The Judicial Member held that judicial discipline required the conflict between the coordinate Bench decisions to be resolved through a reference to a Larger Bench. He therefore refrained from expressing an opinion on the merits and considered that the matter should be placed before the President of the Tribunal for appropriate orders.

Third Member's view

The Third Member observed that the Mumbai Bench's decision in Bank of Baroda v. CST, Mumbai had considered the earlier decision in Punjab National Bank's own case, in which commitment charges were held to be taxable.

He found the Mumbai Bench's decision to be “just and reasonable” and held that it was required to be followed. He held:

“In view of the above clear and convincing ruling of Mumbai Bench, I find that the commitment charges is liable to service tax and hence, the order of Member (Technical) which is in line with the above ruling appears to be just and proper, although for different reasons spelt out in his order.”

In view of the majority opinion, the Tribunal upheld the taxability of commitment charges in terms of the findings and directions of the Technical Member.

However, the Bench held that suppression or misdeclaration had not been established and that the demand could be sustained only for the normal limitation period. It set aside the demand for the extended period and the penalties imposed.

It also granted the bank the benefit of cum-tax calculation, directing that the service tax be recalculated accordingly and interest be computed on the revised amount.

Accordingly, the CESTAT upheld the demand for service tax on commitment charges for the normal limitation period, subject to cum-tax recalculation, while setting aside the extended-period demand and penalties.

For Appellant: Advocate Arun Prasad

For Respondent: Authorised Representative O.M. Reena

Tags:    
Case Title :  Punjab National Bank Ltd. v. Commissioner of GST & Central ExciseCase Number :  Service Tax Appeal No. 40935/2016CITATION :  2026 LLBiz CESTAT(CHE) 660