The Kerala High Court on 18 November held that RERA authorities cannot question the validity of an occupancy certificate issued by a municipal authority or reassess whether a building complies with its sanctioned plan and is fit for occupation.
Justice Mohammed Nias C.P. modified a Kerala Real Estate Appellate Tribunal order directing the Kerala Real Estate Regulatory Authority (K-RERA) to decide 35 complaints concerning the Hoysala EVM project in accordance with the law. The Bench held:
“The grievances that the common areas have not been registered in favour of the Association, that parking slots have not been allotted to all the allottees, that sale deeds are yet to be executed, and that interest is due for delay are matters which the RERA Act commits to its authorities. The grant of the Occupancy Certificate does not prevent the allottees from approaching them. What the authorities under RERA cannot do is to look into the correctness of the Occupancy Certificate and its implication, namely that the building is complete as per the permit and fit for occupation.”
Thrikkakara Municipality issued an occupancy certificate for the Hoysala EVM project on 10 May 2023. Hoysala Projects Private Limited thereafter asked the buyers to clear their outstanding payments and proceed with the execution of sale deeds.
The buyers alleged that the project remained incomplete, common areas had not been registered in favour of their association and parking spaces had not been allotted to some allottees. They also sought execution of sale deeds and interest for delayed possession.
On 7 August 2025, K-RERA declined to examine the issue of building completion but left the buyers' other claims open.
The buyers challenged the decision before the Kerala Real Estate Appellate Tribunal. On 30 July 2026, the Tribunal directed K-RERA to hear the complaints in full after finding that two K-RERA officials had inspected the site without notifying the parties.
Hoysala Projects Private Limited and its directors challenged the Tribunal's direction before the High Court. Hoysala argued that the occupancy certificate established compliance with the sanctioned building permit. The buyers contended that the developer's statutory obligations remained outstanding and alleged fraud in obtaining the certificate.
The Bench examined Rule 20(3) of the Kerala Municipality Building Rules, which requires the municipal secretary to issue an occupancy certificate within 15 days of receiving the completion report if satisfied that the construction conforms to the building permit.
It noted that if no certificate is issued within that period, public authorities must accept the deemed certificate as proof of completion. Rules 20(4) and 20(5) also permit occupation of a partially completed building if the municipal secretary is satisfied that such occupation would not endanger life.
The Court explained that an occupancy certificate establishes compliance with approved building plans and the building's fitness for occupation. It does not determine whether the promoter has fulfilled contractual or statutory obligations towards the allottees. It observed:
“Nothing in the Building Rules deals with the contractual or statutory relationship between a promoter and his allottees based on the agreement entered into between them,”
Justice Nias noted that the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 recognises occupancy and completion certificates issued under local laws. Section 11(4)(b) requires a promoter to obtain the applicable certificate and make it available to the allottees or their association.
However, he explained that RERA authorities retain the power to enforce the promoter's obligations concerning transfer of title and handover of common areas, notwithstanding the issuance of an occupancy certificate.
Further, the Court held that completion under the Building Rules and completion under RERA operate in different spheres. It said:
“Completion therefore carries two meanings. Under the Building Rules, it means that the building is complete as per the permit, which the Occupancy Certificate settles. Under the RERA Act, it also takes in whether the promoter has done all that the Act requires of him towards the allottees, which the certificate does not settle.”
The Bench also held that the absence of notice before the site inspection did not give the Tribunal a basis to reopen an issue outside K-RERA's jurisdiction.
It added that any challenge alleging fraud in obtaining the occupancy certificate had to be brought against the certificate and the issuing authority through the appropriate legal proceedings.
Accordingly, the High Court directed K-RERA to decide the remaining issues in all 35 complaints and endeavour to comply with the timeline prescribed in its judgment dated 11 September 2026.
Appearances for appellants (Hoysala Projects Private Limited and its directors): Senior Advocate E.K. Nandakumar and Advocate Nagaraj Narayanan.
Appearances for respondent (Khalid Sahel): Advocates K. Shaj, Sajju S., Beena N. Kartha, Renjit George, Arun Chand, Varsha K.A., Gopika Gopal, Ren Shibu, Nikhil Krishna A.S., Shehroon Patel A.K., Issac Melvin B.O., Alvin Joseph, Riya Philo Johnson, Febin Fathima, Ishma T.B., Monsu Joseph George.
Appearances for respondents (M/s E.V. Mathai & Sons and its partners): Advocates Nidhi Sam Johns, Lijo Joseph (Thoppil), A. Kevin Thomas.