The Karnataka Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (K-REAT) on 12 November upheld an order directing Space Properties to recognise homebuyer Supriya Sinha's Rs. 7 lakh payment made to a third party on the instructions of its customer relationship manager and register her flat upon receipt of the balance sale consideration.
A Bench comprising Chairperson Justice J.M. Khazi and Judicial Member Santhosh Kumar Shetty N. dismissed Space Properties' appeal against the Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority's (K-RERA) order. It said:
“Even assuming that the CRM had subsequently misappropriated or diverted the amount received from the allottee, such alleged misconduct, by itself, would not absolve the promoter of its liability towards the allottee, provided that the payment was made bona fide under the legitimate belief that the said employee was authorised to receive the amount on behalf of the promoter.”
Sinha booked Flat No. 68 in Space Properties' 'Sohan Serenity' project on 30 March 2024, for a consideration of Rs. 92,31,172.
She paid Rs. 13 lakh directly to the developer in three instalments between 21 March and 11 May 2024. The dispute concerned another Rs. 7 lakh transferred to Venkatesh P.K. on the instructions of the developer's customer relationship manager, Deepak Kumar S.
An invoice bearing Space Properties' seal and the signature of its authorised signatory recorded the Rs. 7 lakh payment towards the flat on 30 May 2024. The developer, however, refused to credit the amount and demanded that Sinha pay it again.
Sinha approached K-RERA seeking recognition of the payment, registration of the flat upon payment of the balance consideration and protection against its transfer to any third party.
On 9 December 2025, K-RERA directed Space Properties to recognise the total payment of Rs. 20 lakh, receive the balance against a total consideration of Rs. 93 lakh stated in its directions and register the sale deed within 60 days. It also restrained the developer from transferring the flat to any third party.
Space Properties challenged the order under Section 44(1) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. It contended that Venkatesh had no connection with the company and that Sinha had failed to exercise due diligence before transferring the money.
The developer relied on a police complaint filed on 19 November 2024, alleging that Deepak Kumar and others had defrauded it by collecting more than Rs. 1 crore from customers.
It further argued that the booking application did not create enforceable rights in the absence of an agreement for sale. It sought permission to cancel the allotment and refund the amount received from Sinha.
Sinha maintained that the disputed amount formed part of the advance paid through the developer's representative.
The Tribunal noted that Deepak Kumar's employment with Space Properties and the instructions issued by him were undisputed. It also relied on the stamped invoice recording the payment towards Sinha's flat.
Applying the principles of agency under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, it held that a promoter cannot disown the acts of its representative when they fall within the scope of his actual or apparent authority. It observed:
“Having regard to the principles of agency embodied in Sections 182, 186, 187, 188, 226 and 237 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the promoter cannot disown the acts of its representative insofar as such acts fall within the scope of his actual or apparent authority.”
The Bench clarified that recognition of the Rs. 7 lakh payment was subject to establishing the genuineness of the invoice and the circumstances in which it was issued.
It added that Space Properties remained free to pursue remedies against the employee and others involved in the alleged fraud. However, the developer could not compel Sinha to pay the amount again merely because its employee had allegedly misappropriated it.
Accordingly, the REAT dismissed the appeal and upheld K-RERA's directions. It made no order as to costs.
Appearances for appellant (M/s. Space Properties): Advocate Dhirendra N. Katti.
Appearances for respondent (Mrs. Supriya Sinha): Advocate Muralimohan.
Appearances for respondent (Karnataka Real Estate Regulatory Authority): Advocate Rajashekhar K.