Odisha REAT Says Ignorance Of RERA Law No Excuse For Advertising Unregistered Project, Upholds Penalty
The Odisha Real Estate Appellate Tribunal on 30 October held that promoters cannot escape liability for advertising an unregistered real estate project by pleading ignorance of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, as developers are expected to possess basic knowledge of real estate laws.
A Bench comprising Judicial Member S.K. Rajguru and Technical/Administrative Member Dr. B.K. Das upheld the Rs. 50 lakh penalty imposed on Pratyaksh Estates Pvt. Ltd. for advertising its Riverdale residential project through hoarding and website advertisements before registering it with the Odisha Real Estate Regulatory Authority (ORERA). It observed:
“The plea of the appellant-promoter that, being unaware of the RERA rules he had mistakenly displayed the advertisement board of his project but had immediately removed it after receiving notice from the learned Authority, are not acceptable as ignorance of law is no excuse. The appellant being a promoter-company engaged in development of real estate projects is expected to possess minimum knowledge in real estate law.”
The dispute arose on 28 March 2024, when an ORERA enforcement officer spotted a hoarding advertising the Riverdale Project beside the Kathajodi river in Cuttack.
During an inspection of the project site at Belgachhia, Trisulia, the construction manager of Pratyaksh Estates informed the officer that the proposed 25-acre project would comprise 100 duplex houses and 253 residential plots. However, the project had not obtained ORERA registration.
The Cuttack Development Authority's committee had conditionally approved the project on 11 January 2024, subject to construction and access clearances concerning the riverfront and government land, as well as powers of attorney from the landowners.
An inspection report dated 9 April 2024, accompanied by photographs and website advertisements, documented the alleged violation. ORERA subsequently initiated suo motu proceedings on 20 April 2024 for violating Section 3(1) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, which prohibits promoters from advertising or offering projects for sale without registration.
Pratyaksh Estates admitted displaying the hoarding but claimed that it was unaware of the RERA requirements and that Riverdale was its first real estate venture. It submitted that it had removed the hoarding upon receiving notice and had not sold any units. It also pointed out that some landowners had not executed the necessary documents and undertook to obtain registration before entering into any sale transactions.
On 18 October 2024, ORERA found a violation of Section 3(1) and imposed a Rs. 50 lakh penalty under Section 59(1) of the Act, which provides for a penalty of up to 10% of the estimated project cost. It also directed the developer to pay the penalty and obtain registration within two months.
Aggrieved, Pratyaksh Estates approached the Tribunal seeking a waiver or reduction of the penalty. It challenged the proceedings on grounds of reliance on unilateral reports, inadequate investigation and violation of principles of natural justice. It also disputed the estimated project cost of Rs. 202.512 crore.
ORERA defended its order, contending that the company's admission of having advertised the project established the violation.
The Tribunal found the violation established through the inspection report, photographs, website printouts and the company's admission. It rejected the developer's plea of ignorance and held that advertising the project before complying with the conditions imposed by the Cuttack Development Authority and obtaining ORERA registration demonstrated a lack of bona fides. It said:
“Putting up the advertisement board when the conditions imposed by the CDA to obtain permission under Section 16(3) of the ODA Act, 1982 had still not been complied with and registration with the ORERA had not been done, clearly shows that the act of the appellant-promoter was not at all bonafide.”
However, the Bench modified the estimated project cost by excluding Rs. 75 crore attributed to the 100 proposed duplex houses, none of which had been constructed. Taking into account the approval dated 3 March 2025 for a residential plotted layout, it revised the project cost to Rs. 127.512 crore.
It noted that the Rs. 50 lakh penalty amounted to only 0.392% of the revised project cost and remained within the statutory ceiling.
Accordingly, the REAT dismissed the appeal and directed Pratyaksh Estates to pay the penalty to ORERA. It also permitted the developer to obtain a refund of the statutory appeal deposit, along with accrued interest, upon submitting the payment receipt and a proper application.
Appearances for appellant (Pratyaksh Estates Pvt. Ltd.): Advocate D.K. Pradhan.
Appearances for respondent (Secretary, ORERA, Bhubaneswar): Advocate B. Nayak.