District Magistrate Cannot Examine Quantum Of Debt, Legality Of SARFAESI Measures: Calcutta High Court
The Calcutta High Court on Monday held that a District Magistrate exercising powers under Section 14 of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest (SARFAESI) Act, 2002, performs a ministerial and executionary function.
It held that the Magistrate is not empowered to adjudicate disputes concerning the quantum of debt or the legality of measures taken by a secured creditor under the Act.
A coram of Dr. Justice Ajoy Kumar Mukherjee observed that the District Magistrate does not become functus officio merely upon passing an initial order authorising possession of secured assets.
The dispute arose after Indian Bank initiated recovery proceedings against borrowers under the SARFAESI Act seeking recovery of ₹1.54 crore.
The Bank issued a demand notice on June 21, 2021, and subsequently initiated recovery measures. The borrowers challenged these measures before the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT).
In the meantime, the Bank approached the District Magistrate, seeking assistance in taking physical possession of two secured assets. On September 21, 2022, the District Magistrate authorised an Executive Magistrate to take possession of both properties.
While the proceedings were pending, the Bank sold one of the secured assets through an e-auction for ₹33.50 lakh. However, in a subsequent order dated November 28, 2023, the District Magistrate again authorised an Executive Magistrate to take possession of the properties, retaining the description of both assets, including the one already sold, and reiterating the original outstanding amount of ₹1.54 crore without accounting for the sale proceeds.
Challenging the subsequent order, the borrowers approached the DRT, which, on February 1, 2024, restrained the Bank from taking further coercive steps pursuant to it. However, the DRAT subsequently allowed the Bank's appeal, set aside the DRT's order and dismissed the borrowers' application.
Aggrieved by the DRAT's decision, the borrowers approached the High Court.
Opposing the appeal, the Bank contended that the District Magistrate's role under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act was limited to facilitating physical possession of secured assets and did not extend to examining the quantum of debt. It further argued that the Magistrate did not become functus officio until possession of all the secured assets was handed over to the secured creditor, as the functions performed under the provision were ministerial, rather than judicial or quasi-judicial.
Agreeing with the Bank's contentions, the Court observed that Section 14 does not confer any adjudicatory power on the Magistrate to examine disputes concerning the secured creditor's claim.
The Court observed that the Magistrate's role under Section 14 is limited to determining whether the property qualifies as a secured asset. If it does not, assistance can be refused; if it does, the Magistrate is bound to assist the secured creditor in taking possession of the property and the related documents.
“No element of quasi judicial function are to be performed by DM or CMM while exercising power under section 14 of the Act but he is only require to perform act of executionery in nature in taking possession and delivering it to secured creditor….section 14 does not empower CMM or DM to adjudicate dispute nor empower it to decide question whether claim of secured creditor was genuine or not.” it held
On the issue of the quantum of debt, the Bench clarified:
“under section 14 of the Act of 2002, the learned Magistrate is nothing to do with the quantum of debts”
Rejecting the borrowers' contention that the District Magistrate had become functus officio, the Bench clarified that the Magistrate has a statutory obligation under Section 14 to take physical possession of the secured assets and hand them over to the secured creditor. It held that the authority does not become functus officio until possession of all the secured assets has been delivered to the creditor.
Finding no merit in the borrowers' challenge, the Court dismissed the application.
For Petitioner: Advocates Suddhasatwa Banerjee, Shashwat Nayak, Sagnik Roy Chowdhury, Mitul Chakraborty, Payel Nath and Trijit Mitra
For Respondent: Advocate Shiv Mangal Singh