The Chhattisgarh High Court has refused to interfere with an ex parte order directing a company to pay ₹24.04 lakh to a lubricant supplier, observing that writ jurisdiction cannot replace the statutory forum for deciding disputed commercial claims.
A bench of Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad observed:
“...The writ jurisdiction of this Court is not intended to substitute for the statutory forum in the determination of disputed contractual or commercial claims, particularly where the petitioner had an opportunity to participate in the proceedings but did not do so...”
The bench added that no independent ground of patent jurisdictional error or manifest illegality had been demonstrated to justify interference under Article 226 of the Constitution.
The company, which is engaged in coal excavation and transportation in Chhattisgarh, challenged the MSEFC's order, arguing that it was passed without proper service of notice or an effective opportunity of hearing.
It also alleged that the Council had failed to follow the conciliation and arbitration procedure under Section 18 of the Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006.
The court noted that notices had been sent through the Samadhan web portal and WhatsApp and that the company had not appeared before the Council or filed a reply disputing the supplier's claim.
It observed that mere non-appearance did not establish that the proceedings were vitiated for want of an opportunity of hearing.
The bench further noted that the company could challenge the Council's order under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, read with Section 19 of the MSMED Act, which prescribes a pre-deposit requirement.
Although the availability of an alternative remedy does not absolutely bar writ jurisdiction, the company had failed to establish any recognised ground to bypass the statutory remedy, the court ruled.
The writ petition was accordingly dismissed. The court clarified that it had not independently adjudicated the underlying commercial claim.
For Petitioner: Advocate Apoorva Tripathi
For Respondent: Advocate Soumitra Kesharwani on behalf of Advocate Apurv Goyal.