The Bombay High Court has held that advances received by a developer towards the purchase of flats cannot be treated as 'deposits' under the Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors (in Financial Establishments) Act, 1999 (MPID Act).
A division bench of Justices A.S. Gadkari and Kamal Khata made the observation while dismissing a petition seeking directions to the Maharashtra Police to apply the provisions of the MPID Act in a case involving allegations that a developer had failed to hand over flats despite receiving ₹6.51 crore from purchasers.
"According to us, the money received by the Respondent Nos. 3 to 5 under the five Agreements, was an advance payment specifically towards purchase of flats and cannot be termed as 'deposit' under section 2(c) of the MPID Act," the Court held.
The petitioner, Bailor Raghvendra Shetty, was the first informant in a criminal case concerning a redevelopment project of Suryakiran Co-operative Housing Society Ltd, Building No. 7, D.N. Nagar, Mumbai.
Sai Siddhant Developers had entered into agreements with Shetty and other purchasers for the sale of flats. The developer allegedly received ₹6.51 crore but failed to hand over possession within the stipulated period and misappropriated the amounts.
Before the High Court, Shetty argued that the agreements contained a clause requiring the developer to refund the amounts received with simple interest at 9% per annum if possession was not handed over within the stipulated period. He contended that the failure to honour this obligation attracted the provisions of the MPID Act.
Rejecting the argument, the Court noted that possession of two of the five flats covered by the agreements had already been handed over to the petitioner and/or other witnesses.
It observed that the agreements had therefore been partially acted upon, indicating that the developer had partly performed its contractual obligations. At most, the petitioner would be entitled to a refund with 9% interest in accordance with the agreed terms.
The Court further held that the failure to hand over flats and alternatively return the money with agreed interest did not constitute an offence under Sections 3 or 4 of the MPID Act.
"In our considered view, failure to hand over flats and alternatively return money with agreed interest, does not constitute offence as contemplated under Section 3 or Section 4 of the MPID Act," the bench observed.
The court also noted that the developer firm and its partners had not assured or guaranteed the petitioner exorbitant interest on deposits contrary to the Reserve Bank of India guidelines.
For Petitioner: Kushal Mor, Sarthak P. Shetty, Advocates
For Respondent State: Madhavi H. Mhatre, APP.