On 17 November, the Meghalaya High Court held that tax authorities cannot invoke the best judgment assessment mechanism under Section 45 of the Meghalaya Value Added Tax Act, 2003, without satisfying its mandatory statutory conditions, and quashed assessment orders covering nearly 10 years.

A Division Bench comprising Justices H.S. Thangkhiew and B. Bhattacharjee allowed a petition filed by Megha Technical and Engineers Pvt. Ltd. challenging sales tax assessment orders passed by the Superintendent of Taxes, East Jaintia Hills, for the period from the quarter ending 30 June 2007 to the quarter ending 30 June 2017. It observed:

“Best judgment assessment mandatorily, has to be completed in such a manner as strictly prescribed in the rules, and in the instant case what is apparent is that there has been a misapplication of the provisions, inasmuch as, Section 45 and Section 55 operate in separate fields and therefore the notice cannot be taken to be one under Section 45, as it asks only for production of books of accounts which would by its content and intent make it at the most, a notice under Section 55”.

The dispute arose from a notice dated 27 April 2017, which the department relied upon to initiate best judgment assessment proceedings under Section 45 of the MVAT Act.

The petitioner contended that the notice was issued for production of books of accounts for the purpose of audit assessment under Section 55 and could not be treated as a notice under Section 45. It argued that Section 45 could be invoked only where a registered dealer failed to furnish returns within the prescribed time or where the Commissioner was not satisfied that the returns furnished were correct and complete.

Opposing the petition, the State argued that the assessments had been validly undertaken under Section 45 of the MVAT Act read with Section 9(2) of the Central Sales Tax Act. It submitted that Section 45 permitted assessments where returns were incomplete or incorrect and did not prescribe any limitation period.

Examining Section 45(1), the Court noted that the provision permits best judgment assessment where a registered dealer fails to furnish returns within the prescribed time or where the Commissioner is not satisfied that the returns furnished are correct and complete. In the latter situation, the dealer must be given a reasonable opportunity of being heard before an assessment is made.

It found that the petitioner was a registered dealer which had filed its returns and paid the applicable taxes. Therefore, the first condition for invoking Section 45 was not satisfied.

Examining the second condition, the Bench found that the notice dated 27 April 2017 merely called upon the petitioner to produce its books of accounts for completion of audit assessment. It also stated that the assessment would be completed through the best judgment method in case of non-compliance.

It held that the notice, by its contents and purpose, was one for initiating proceedings under Section 55 and could not be treated as a notice under Section 45 affording the petitioner a reasonable opportunity of being heard. It observed:

“The notice dated 27.04.2017 in the considered view of this Court, would therefore amount to a notice for initiation of proceedings under Section 55 of the MVAT Act, 2003 which however, for the period in question that is 01.05.05 to 31.12.16, would also have to meet the limitation requirements of Section 57 for the relevant periods therein. As such therefore, it can safely be concluded there was no valid notice of affording reasonable opportunity of being heard to the Petitioner.”

Further, the judges examined Section 55(5) of the MVAT Act, which provides for best judgment assessment in specified circumstances, including failure to furnish returns, submission of incomplete or incorrect returns, failure to comply with statutory notices and failure to maintain accounts in accordance with the Act.

They noted that Section 57 prescribes a five-year limitation period for assessments under Sections 55 and 56. Since the notice dated 27 April 2017 was, in substance, issued for audit assessment under Section 55, the proceedings were also required to comply with the limitation prescribed under Section 57.

Therefore, the Court concluded that the department had misapplied the provisions of the MVAT Act by treating a notice for production of books of accounts under Section 55 as a notice for best judgment assessment under Section 45.

On the question of maintainability, it held that the writ petition was maintainable as the mandatory preconditions for invoking Section 45 had not been fulfilled. It also found a clear violation of the principles of natural justice, apart from the jurisdictional issues involved. It observed:

“On the issue of maintainability, on the mandatory pre-conditions prescribed by Section 45 not having been met, and there being a clear violation of the principles of natural justice, apart from the jurisdictional issues discussed, the writ petition is therefore maintainable.”

Relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Kunwar Pal Singh v. State of U.P., the Bench reiterated that where a statute prescribes a particular manner for exercising a power, the authority must follow that procedure and cannot assume jurisdiction through a method not authorised by law.

It also noted that the issue concerning delegation of powers to the Superintendent of Taxes had been rendered redundant in view of its findings on the failure to comply with the statutory requirements under Section 45.

Accordingly, the High Court quashed the assessment orders and allowed the writ petition

For the petitioner: Dr. A. Saraf, Senior Advocate, assisted by S.J. Saikia, Advocate.

For the respondents: A. Kumar, Advocate General, assisted by N. Syngkon, J.N. Rynjah and S. Laloo, Government Advocates.

Tags:    
Case Title :  Megha Technical and Engineers Pvt. Ltd. v. The State of MeghalayaCase Number :  WP(C) No. 60 of 2024CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (MEG) 6