Delhi High Court Rejects MCD's Plea To Levy Higher Property Tax On HUDCO's Residential Flats And Transit Hostels
The Delhi High Court has dismissed a petition filed by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) seeking to levy higher property tax on 18 flats owned by the Housing and Urban Development Corporation Limited (HUDCO), holding that providing transit accommodation to officials at nominal charges does not automatically amount to commercial use of the property.
Justice Amit Bansal upheld the Municipal Taxation Tribunal's decision setting aside the civic body's assessment order and consequential demand of approximately ₹72 lakh in differential property tax.
The Court observed that merely charging different accommodation rates from government officials and other persons visiting the premises in connection with official work would not establish that the flats were being used for commercial purposes or profit-making activities.
"MTT has correctly held that merely because there are different slab rates for the persons visiting the subject flats does not imply that the subject flats are being used for commercial purposes or for making profit," the Court said.
The dispute concerned 18 flats owned by HUDCO at Asian Games Village, Siri Fort Road, New Delhi. Of these, six flats were used as residences for senior HUDCO officers and officials of the Ministry of Urban Development, while the remaining 12 were used as transit hostel accommodation for officials, researchers, consultants and participants in training programmes.
HUDCO had been paying property tax on these flats since 2004-05 by applying Use Factor-1 (UF-1), applicable to residential properties.
However, MCD contended that the flats were being used as guest houses and lodging facilities and should therefore attract Use Factor-4 (UF-4), applicable to commercial properties.
In September 2013, the civic body reassessed the properties by applying UF-4 retrospectively from April 2004 and raised a demand of ₹71,98,231 towards differential property tax.
HUDCO challenged the assessment before the Municipal Taxation Tribunal, which allowed its appeals in August 2018. MCD subsequently approached the High Court against the Tribunal's decision.
The High Court noted that the assessment was based solely on HUDCO's office orders prescribing different accommodation charges for different categories of occupants.
It observed that the civic body had no independent material to establish that the flats were being rented out for commercial purposes.
"There was no independent material with the petitioner/MCD to show that the subject flats were rented out for commercial purposes. There is no analysis also to the fact whether the tariffs mentioned in the office order are commercial rates when compared to other comparable accommodation available in the area," the Court said.
The Court also referred to its earlier decisions concerning the Bar Council of India and the Indian Council of Forestry Research and Education, which dealt with the application of property tax use factors to premises used for public purposes and transit accommodation.
It consequently found no infirmity in the Tribunal's decision holding that UF-1 was applicable to HUDCO's flats.
On the issue of retrospective reassessment, the High Court further held that MCD could not reopen property tax assessments beyond the prescribed period of 12 months without establishing wilful suppression of information.
It held that MCD's action in reopening the assessments for the period 2004-05 to 2011-12 was "manifestly arbitrary and illegal."
For Petitioner: Advocates Madhu Tewatia and Mr. Adhirath Singh
For Respondent: Senior Advocate Pawanjit Singh Bindra, with Advocates Abhishek Aggarwal and Neha Narang,