ON 18 November, the Karnataka High Court held that a writ court cannot direct a tribunal to allow a deemed export tax benefit without examining whether the prescribed Form-H declarations were mandatory.

A Bench comprising Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice K.S. Hemalekha allowed the Revenue's sales tax revision petition filed against Shree Renuka Sugars Ltd. (SRSL), set aside the Single Judge's directions to the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal (KAT) and restored the pending appeal of Karnataka State Beverages Corporation Limited (KSBCL) for fresh consideration. It held:

“In our view, the impugned order inasmuch as it holds that there is no dispute that since SRSL had exported the goods in question, KSBCL's claim for exemption would have to be accepted, cannot be sustained as it fails to address the question whether it was mandatory to furnish the necessary declarations in the prescribed forms…”

The dispute concerned the tax treatment of exports of denatured ethanol through KSBCL, the authorised canalising agency for such exports under the applicable Karnataka Excise Rules.

The Revenue raised a tax and interest demand of Rs. 1,86,92,460 against KSBCL under the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, alleging that it had not furnished the prescribed Form-H declarations to substantiate its claim for deemed export benefits.

KSBCL challenged the reassessment before the appellate authorities. While its second appeal was pending before the KAT, SRSL approached the High Court challenging KSBCL's invocation of an indemnity bond and withholding of amounts payable to it.

The Single Judge allowed the writ petition and directed the KAT to decide KSBCL's pending appeal in its favour. The Single Judge proceeded on the basis that the goods had admittedly been exported and, therefore, the tax demand could not be sustained.

The Division Bench held that the Single Judge ought to have confined the examination to the dispute between SRSL and KSBCL concerning their inter se obligations, including the invocation of the indemnity bond. The validity of the tax reassessment was already before the KAT in statutory proceedings and could not have been decided in the writ proceedings.

The judges noted that the Revenue had produced material showing that KSBCL had declared the relevant turnover as deemed exports in its returns but had not furnished the prescribed Form-H declarations. However, the Single Judge had not examined whether furnishing those declarations was mandatory to claim the benefit of deemed exports.

Further, the Bench held that the Single Judge could not have directed the Tribunal to treat the transactions as deemed exports and relieve KSBCL of its tax liability without examining the applicable statutory requirements. It said:

“It is also noted that the impugned order rests solely on the basis that the KSBCL is not liable to pay tax and interest as assessed by the Revenue. Since the learned Single Judge's decision in this regard is ex-facie erroneous, the impugned order cannot be sustained…”

Therefore, the Bench set aside the Single Judge's order and remanded the writ petition for fresh consideration. It directed the Single Judge to examine whether the dispute was appropriate for adjudication under Article 226 of the Constitution.

It also set aside the consequential order directing implementation of the earlier judgment and the subsequent order passed by the KAT in compliance with those directions. It restored KSBCL's second appeal before the KAT for fresh consideration, uninfluenced by the orders set aside by the High Court.

The judges clarified that it had not expressed any opinion on whether furnishing Form-H declarations was mandatory or whether KSBCL was entitled to the benefit of deemed exports. It left both questions open for the Tribunal to decide.

Accordingly, the High Court disposed of the applications.

For the Revenue: Additional Government Advocate Aditya Vikram Bhat

For Respondent No. 1: P.N. Manmohan and Vinay N., Advocates

For Respondents Nos. 2 and 3: Sumana Baliga, Advocate

Tags:    
Case Title :  The Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Audit) v. M/s Shree Renuka Sugars Ltd.Case Number :  WRIT APPEAL NO. 1153 OF 2025 (EXCISE)CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (KAR) 240