The Supreme Court on Friday dismissed the Competition Commission of India's (CCI) challenge to the Bombay High Court's October 16, 2019, order quashing the Commission's directions for an investigation against Star India Private Limited and Sony Pictures Network India Private Limited over alleged anti-competitive practices in the television broadcasting sector.

The High Court held that the CCI had failed to record the requisite prima facie finding of an agreement involving refusal to deal and its appreciable adverse effect on competition and had also failed to analyse the relevant factors under Section 19(3) of the Competition Act.

A division bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran declined to interfere with the High Court's decision, taking note of the fact that the CCI's special leave petition had remained pending for nearly six years without being taken up even for admission.

At the outset, the Court questioned the CCI over its failure to ensure that the matter was listed for admission despite the passage of six years. The Bench observed that the challenge concerned a 2019 order and that no effective steps appeared to have been taken to have the matter listed.

“It has been six years. You have not even got notice issued in the matter.”, Justice Pardiwala asked. 

The Bench then questioned the CCI, asking, “What steps have you taken in the last six years to at least get it notified for the purpose of admission?”

Appearing for the CCI, counsel sought to explain the delay and informed the Court that an early hearing application had been moved in 2020 and again in 2022. Counsel also submitted that the matter had been mentioned before the Registry in 2022 and that documents supporting these steps could be placed before the Court.

When the Bench questioned the delay, counsel attempted to explain that the matter had not been taken up earlier for reasons relating to its listing and allocation before different Benches. Counsel requested the Court to consider the steps taken to secure an early hearing.

The bench, however, remained unconvinced and reiterated that the petition had not even reached the stage of admission despite having been filed several years earlier.

Background

The dispute arose from a complaint filed by Noida Software Technology Park Limited (NSTPL), a television channel distributor, alleging that the broadcasters had imposed discriminatory terms and refused to provide it with fair and non-discriminatory access to their channels.

NSTPL had entered into interconnection agreements with content aggregators distributing Star and Sony channels. It alleged that the broadcasters offered preferential rates and discounts to other distribution platform operators while imposing unfair commercial terms on it.

On June 7, 2017, NSTPL approached the CCI alleging violations of Sections 3 and 4 of the Competition Act. Acting on the complaint, the CCI passed orders dated July 27 and 31, 2018 directing its Director General to investigate the alleged discriminatory refusal to deal.

Star India and Sony challenged the CCI's orders before the Bombay High Court. The High Court in its October 16, 2019 judgment, allowed both petitions and quashed the CCI orders along with consequential actions and notices issued by the Director General. 

Click Here To Download Bombay HC Order

Tags:    
Case Title :  COMPETITION COMMISSION OF INDIA VS. STAR INDIA PRIVATE LIMITEDCase Number :  DIARY NO. - 3222/2020