The Calcutta High Court has set aside the discharge of a former State Bank of India (SBI) Chief Manager in a ₹164.99 crore banking fraud case, holding that the trial court had impermissibly evaluated the prosecution evidence at the pre-charge stage.
“Upon a holistic appraisal of the charge sheet materials, system logs, unbacked fund transfers, and regulatory submissions, this Court has no hesitation in holding that the prosecution evidence establishes a strong and grave suspicion of criminal conspiracy, cheating, and abuse of official position against the Opposite Party (A-3). The trial court patently erred in treating these active overt acts as innocuous administrative oversights.” Justice Uday Kumar held
The case arose from an alleged banking fraud of over ₹164.99 crore involving Shree Mahalaxmi Corporation Private Limited (SMCPL), which had availed credit facilities worth ₹142.89 crore from a consortium led by the SBI.
According to the CBI, between 2011 and 2013, the company and its associate entities misused the credit facilities by depositing cheques drawn on accounts with insufficient funds under the Cash Management Product (CMP) facility, obtaining Letters of Credit through fabricated documents and submitting false stock and book-debt statements to inflate drawing powers. The company's account was classified as a non performing asset in June 2013 and declared fraudulent in June 2015.
The CBI alleged that Jyoti Ranjan Kanungo, then Chief Manager and Relationship Manager at SBI's Industrial Finance Branch, Kolkata, facilitated the fraud by allowing the CMP facility to continue despite repeated cheque returns, enabling excess borrowing, facilitating an unauthorised ₹14.89 crore transfer, opening an unauthorised account to cover an unbacked ₹15 crore RTGS exposure to Emami Biotech Limited, and understating the borrower's liabilities in reports to delay NPA classification.
Following registration of an FIR in March 2017, the CBI filed a charge sheet against 11 accused, including Kanungo, alleging offences under the Indian Penal Code and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. However, the Special CBI Court discharged him under Section 239 of the Criminal Procedure Code, finding that the material did not disclose criminal intent or personal financial gain.
The CBI challenged the discharge before the High Court.
The Court first held that the trial court had committed a patent jurisdictional error by conducting an impermissible “mini-trial” and assessing the credibility of the evidence while considering the discharge application under Section 239 of CrPC.
Referring to the Supreme Court's decisions in State of Tamil Nadu v. N. Suresh Rajan and Sajjan Kumar v. CBI, the Court observed that, at the stage of discharge, the court must examine whether the prosecution materials, taken at face value, disclose the ingredients of the alleged offences.
“Evaluating whether these documents were executed innocently or as part of a design requires a full-fledged trial where oral testimony and cross-examination can test their veracity. By accepting the defence interpretation of these documents and relying on departmental warnings at the pre-charge stage, the learned trial court directly violated the ratio of N. Suresh Rajan (supra) and Sajjan Kumar (supra).” it held
On the question of whether the materials disclosed grave suspicion against Kanungo, the Court, relying on the Supreme Court's decision in State of Maharashtra v. Ishwar Piraji Kalpatri, reiterated that charges must be framed where the prosecution materials raise grave suspicion against the accused. It observed that at this stage, the court is not required to determine whether the evidence would be sufficient to secure a conviction.
Rejecting the argument that the absence of personal monetary gain ruled out an offence under the Prevention of Corruption Act, the Court observed that Section 13(1)(d)(ii) also covers a public servant who, by abusing his official position, secures a pecuniary advantage for another person without public interest.
“Where a bank official acts in active tandem with private fraudsters to funnel public funds and artificially sustain an NPA, the statutory ingredients of abuse of position to grant pecuniary advantage to the borrower (SMCPL) are prima facie satisfied.” it stated
The Bench held that the unauthorised account creation, ₹14.89 crore fund transfer, ₹15 crore RTGS exposure absorbed for Emami Biotech and signed reports concealing the borrower's outstanding liabilities went beyond mere suspicion.
“They establish a strong and grave suspicion of active complicity, criminal conspiracy, cheating, and abuse of official position against the Opposite Party under Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.” it held
Accordingly, the Court allowed the application, quashed the Special Judge's order and directed the trial court to restore the proceedings against Kanungo.
For Petitioner: Advocate Amajit De
For Opposite Party: Advocates Aritra Bhattacharya, Saptarshi Basu and Suman Dutta